Akeisha wrote to me with some terribly good questions. I've included her letter (and my responses) below:
Hi,
It's Akeisha again.
I do see what you mean if it's on all the time the canine will soon forget it is on and then will behave regardless. Ok, so the canine never wears a buckle collar again? This can be what irks me. I want to be in a position to control the dog regardless of what collar is on not simply the pinch or it could be no collar in the least and the dog still behaves. What if the owner for some reason takes to the air the collar then they put the buckle collar on for ID but then forget the pinch collar? Then there's no control.
[Adam Replies] WRONG! The dog gets conditioned. Commence the collar for awhile. Doesn't matter.
Does one ever within the training return to the buckle collar once months of what you recommend with a canine that's pleased with doing the commands?
[Adam Replies] Yes, the canine does the command as a result of he's happy and he likes it. But eventually, there will be something that tempts him. This can be where conditioning comes in.
Think of it like this: You have lived in the same house for ten years, right? You arise in the center of the night and you reach for the sunshine switch that is to the LEFT of the door. Pretty soon, you get conditioned to succeed in out to the LEFT of the door.
In the future you travel and keep during a hotel. You get up in the center of the night and reach out to the LEFT of the door for the switch... even though you cognitively saw {that the} switch is on the RIGHT.
After all, you may wake up for several nights-- maybe even weeks or months-- and still reach out to the LEFT, although the switch is currently on the right. Some folks can continue attending to the LEFT for the rest of their lives. Some will begin planning to the right.
Those individuals need to be reinforced. Get it?
Motivational corrections if on the right dog will not frighten them or make them hate you I understand but are not there other ways that except using the collar that can eventually be established thought coaching that will enable you to require the collar off and have control?
[Adam Replies] Yeah, this method you'll take the collar off and have management, ONCE THE DOG IS CONDITIONED. However eventually you'll have to go back and reinforce, for most dogs. And undoubtedly if you start expecting to figure the canine around new distractions that it's never been proofed around, such as chickens if the canine has never seen chickens.
Look, I do not make the rules. The dog is not a robot that you'll be able to suddenly say, "He is done" and expect him to act consistently for the remainder of his life. Like every relationship you have with another person, boundaries need to be established and maintained. The dog is like your wife or husband... they can eventually take a look at you. 
Last question , how can the dog not realize the do not have it on since it feels a ton completely different than the buckle? Its like my id around my neck at faculty I've got gotten used to it but I do understand when it's off? Just for the record I have no downside with pinches, many members in my 4-H club use them and that they work nice on the right canine.
[Adam Replies] As a result of the approach you must be using the pinch collar is {that the} canine (since he has limited reason and logic) will not KNOW that it is the pinch collar that allows you to relinquish him good corrections. However it's more than the pinch collar. If I put the canine in a variety of little yards, with no collar on ... and I am in a position to chase him down and build him come back back to me, if he doesn't return after I call... then the dog will learn THE UNDERLYING PREMISE that I can build him do it, if he doesn't. Thus, the pinch collar and therefore the long line build my job easier, however ultimately, the dog knows (or he thinks at least) that I am a person of my word and after I tell him to do something: If he doesn't do it, I am going to form him do it. And his life will be a heap more fun if he will it willingly. Thus the dog starts to extrapolate this principle to different commands, too.
Hope I'm not being irritating I simply like to know why certain trainers value bound methods over others since I really like competing in obedience with my canine. Read more other useful information about humana one health insurance, catastrophic medical insurance and pos health insurance
Related Reading:
